Information on Loughborough

Report sheds new light on challenges faced by ex-prisoners

Posted on 28/12/2008

Loughborough University Website

Report sheds new light on challenges faced by ex-prisoners

A study by Loughborough University’s Centre for Research in Social Policy (CRSP) has offered up a fresh insight into ex-prisoners’ experiences of employment and the difficulties they face when trying to re-settle into the community.

The report, High hopes: Supporting ex-prisoners in their lives after prison, was undertaken for the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). It will help to inform the provision of support to ex-prisoners, with a view to improving their employment outcomes and helping to reduce re-offending.

For the study the Loughborough research team comprising Yvette Hartfree, Chris Dearden and Elspeth Pound charted the journey of 40 male ex-prisoners over a six month period following their release from prison. They conducted a three-stage interview process, beginning just prior to the prisoners’ release, with follow-up interviews conducted three and then six months after their release. The researchers also talked to service providers, including employment and benefit advisers and housing/homeless agencies.

“The report aims to provide the DWP and other relevant agencies with a better understanding of the expectations of, and the barriers faced by, ex-prisoners in the first few months after they are released from prison,” explains Yvette Hartfree.

“It looks at how they managed the financial transition from prison back into the community and their interactions with service providers. It also explores their experiences of housing and substance misuse on release which, although not intended to be a main focus of the research, were key issues raised by ex-prisoners.”

The study revealed that:

  • Many prisoners left prison with high hopes for their future plans, for example to move into employment, education or training, and stay off drugs and out of prison. However, these plans were often made in the absence of timely joined-up advice and support and, in some cases, were unrealistic. As a consequence plans often fell apart when the ex-prisoners were faced with the realities of sorting out their lives. Those who had the support of friends and family tended to fare better.
  • The greatest need for support was just before release and in the period shortly afterwards when it becomes apparent that the plans made in prison may not work out. With support, some people in the study sample were able to make positive changes in their lives.
  • The ex-prisoners may have benefited from more help in dealing with the realities of the labour market, such as advice on how to cope with or avoid multiple moves in and out of work, how to disclose criminal records, and how to accept that they may need to take jobs that they do not wish to do.
  • Employment status was more a reflection of circumstances in relation to substance misuse and housing, rather than criminal activity.
  • Many who remained on benefits found financial management a continual struggle. Those who did not have family and friends to turn to for support suffered the most financial hardship. Moving into employment usually meant that people were better off.
  • For those with problems with substance misuse, abstinence after release was a priority and perceived to be key to helping them become crime-free and gain stability in their lives. However, many found it difficult to access on-going support outside prison and relapse was therefore common.
  • Stable housing after release is critical and the absence of this, for some, impacted negatively on their goals to find employment or become drug-free, for instance. Ex-prisoners with no accommodation to go to on their release were often unsure where to seek housing advice. A lack of suitable accommodation also meant some were at increased risk of re-offending, re-engaging in substance abuse or falling back into crime re-offending, substance abuse and housing problems were closely entwined amongst the study sample.